Just like in the FITH fnf mod, anyone killed by Abnormal (Fire in the Hole) can NOT respawn. Iirc 1 and 2 both died from an explosion, which is why they could respawn. It only counts as a permadeath if they’re killed directly by Abnormal, like for example, Amogus and Firey Underwear. Bambi could only be revived because he’s a god.